Poverty as a Violation of Human Rights: the Case of Street Children in Guatemala and Brazil
Résumé
Although human rights are officially regarded by the United Nations as indivisible, interrelated and interdependent, it is largely recognised the gap concerning mechanisms for adjudication between civil and political rights compared to economic, social and cultural ones. The very existence of an individual right not to be poor is still controversial within both – domestic and global societies. Consequently, the responsibility for providing individuals with rights such as food, water, shelter and education, although doubtless related to human dignity, have been constantly denied by states and by the international community. By analysing two cases of extrajudicial execution of street children in the American continent, this paper aims to address the debate of poverty as a violation of human rights considered as an option for judicial enforcement of economic, social and cultural rights. This article undertakes a qualitative analysis on jurisprudence, as well as literature and documents concerning the adjudication of such rights by the Inter-American Court. While taking an integrated approach to human rights, the links between poverty and vulnerability to other sorts of violations, such as urban violence, will be demonstrated. This paper will suggest that the adoption of the new Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) shall act as a supervisory mechanism to guaranteeing international implementation of social justice.
Keywords: poverty, human rights, street children, violence.
Mots-clés
Texte intégral :
PDF (Português (Brasil))Références
ALSTON, Philip. No Right to Complain About Being
Poor: The Need for an Optional Protocol to the Economic
Rights Covenant. In ASBJORN Eide & JAN
Helgesen (Eds.)The Future of Human Rights Protection in a
Changing World: Fifty Years Since the Four Freedoms Address:
Essays in Honour of Torkel Opsahl. Oslo: Norwegian University
Press, 1991, 79-100.
Amnesty Int’l Campaign Journal UK. On the streets, Issue
, March/April 1999.
Amnesty Int’l Newsletter. Brazil: Child victims of killing
and cruelty, Vol. XX, N. 9, Sep. 1990.
Amnesty Int’l Newsletter. Guatemala: children abused by
police, Vol. XX, N. 8, Aug. 1990.
Amnesty Int’l Report 2010. Available at http://therereport.amnesty.org,
last visited Aug. 3, 2010.
Amnesty Int’l. Guatemala: extrajudicial executions and human
rights violations against street children. London: International
Secretariat, July 1990.
BAXI, Upendra. Taking Suffering Seriously: Social
Action Litigation in the Supreme Court of India. In:
BAXI, Upendra. Law and Poverty. Bombay: Tripathi,
, 399.
BAXI, Upendra. From human rights to the right to be
human: some heresies. Ind. Int’l. Q., 187, 1986.
BEZERRA DE MELLO, Yvonne. Interviewed by Joaquim
Pinto and Nuno Leonel, Sep. 3, 1997 available at
www.youtube.com/watch?v=N8X2rNh90bw, [original
in Portuguese, translated by the author], last visited Aug.
, 2010.
Bus 174 (film): Brazil (2002), produced by Zazen Produções
and written by José Padilha, language: Portuguese:
min.
CESCR. Statement on Poverty and the ICESCR. 25th sess.,
at 1, U.N. Doc. E/C.12/2001/10, 2001.
CESCR. The Maastricht Guidelines on Violations of Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights. 24th Sess., U.N. Doc.
E/C.12/2000/13, 2010.
COHEN, Stanley. Seu, Bruna. Knowing enough not to
feel too much: emotional thinking about human rights
appeals. In BRADLEY, M.P., PETRO, P. Truth Claims:
Representation and Human Rights. London: Rutgers University
Press, 2008, 187-204.
DENNIS, M. J and STEWART, D. P. Justiciability of
Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Should there be
an International Complaints Mechanism to Adjudicate
the Rights to Food, Water, Housing and Health? American
Journal of International Law, 98, 462-515, 2004.
FROMM, Erich. The Art of Loving. London: Thorsons,
GAURI, Varun and BRINKS, Daniel. M. Introduction:
The Elements of Legalization and the Triangular Shape
of Social and Economic Rights. In: GAURI, Varun and
BRINKS, Daniel. M. (Eds.). Courting Social Justice: Judicial
Enforcement of Social and Economic Rights in the Developing
World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008.
Human Rights Watch. Brazil: Curb Police Violence in Rio,
São Paulo: extrajudicial killings undermine public security,
(Dec. 8, 2009), available at www.hrw.org/americas/brazil,
last visited Aug. 3, 2010.
Human Rights Watch. Universal Periodic Review of Guatemala:
Police abuses, May 4, 2008, available at www.hrw.
org/americas/guatemala, last visited Aug. 3, 2010.
I/A Court H.R. “Case of the Street Children” Villagran
–Morales and others v Guatemala, Preliminary Objections.
Series C N. 32, 4, Sep. 11, 1997, available at www.corteidh.or.cr/docs/casos/articulos/series_32_ing.doc, last visited Nov. 14, 2009.
I/A Court H.R. “Case of the Street Children” Villagran
–Morales and others v Guatemala, Merits, Series C N.63, 13
(Nov. 19, 1999) available at www.corteidh.or.cr/docs/
casos/articulos/seriec_63_ing.pdf, last visited July 21,
I/A Court H.R. Case of the “Street Children” Villagran
–Morales and others v Guatemala, Concurring Opinion of
Judges Cançado Trindade and Abreu Burelli, Series C
N. 63, 1, Nov. 19, 1999, available at www.corteidh.or.cr/
docs/casos/votos/vsc_cancadoabreu_63_ing.doc, last
visited Nov. 14, 2009.
IACHR. Report on the situation of Human Rights in Brazil.
Chapter V: Violence against minors, Sep. 29, 1997, available
at: http://www.cidh.oas.org/countryrep/brazil-eng/
chaper%205%20.htm, last visited July 8, 2010.
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural
Rights. Joint Committee on Human Rights 21st Report
of Sess. 2003-2004, Nov. 2, 2004, available at:
www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/jt200304/jtselect/
jtrights/183/18305.htm, last visited July 8, 2010.
LADERCHI, Caterina Ruggeri, SAITH, Ruhi and STEWART,
Frances. Does it Matter that we do not Agree
on the Definition of Poverty? A Comparison of Four
Approaches. Oxford Development Studies, 31:3, 243,
Limburg Principles on the Implementation of the ICESCR.
Human Rights Quarterly, 9, 122-135, 1987.
MANTOUVALOU, Virginia. Work and Private Life:
Sidabras and Dziautas v Lithuania, European Law Review:
(4), 573-585, 2005.
Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights. G.A.Res. 63.117, U.N.GAOR,
rd Sess., U.N.Doc. A/RES/63/117, Dec. 10, 2008.
ROBINSON, Mary. Advancing Economic, Social, and
Cultural Rights: The Way Forward. Human Rights
Quarterly: 26, 872, 2004.
SCOTT, Craig. The Interdependence and Permeability
of Human Rights Norms: Towards a Partial Fusion of
the International Covenants on Human Rights. Osgoode
Hall L.J, 27, 771, 1989.
SEN, Amartya. Development as Freedom. Oxford: Oxford
University Press, 1999.
STEINER, Henry, ALSTON, Philip and GODMAN,
Ryan. International Human Rights in Context: Law, Politics and
Morals. 3rd edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008.
The Cocoyoc Declaration. International Organization.
Vol. 29, n. 3, 893. International Responses to
Technology, University of Wisconsin Press, summer
, available at http://websie.eclac.cl/mmp/doc/
Cocoyocdeclaration1974.pdf.
The Council on Hemispheric Affairs (COHA), 16 Years
After Candelária Massacre Impunity and Death Squads Still
Roam Brazil Streets, COHA’s Research Associate Leonardo
Faria Chusán, July 24, 2009, available at www.coha.
org, last visited July 8, 2010.
TURNER, Bryant. Vulnerability and Human Rights: essays
on human rights. Pennsylvania: The Pennsylvania State
University Press, 2006.
UNHCHR. Claiming the Millenium Development Goals: A
Human Rights Approach, 2008.
UNHCHR. What are human rights? Available at: www.
ohchr.org/EN/Issues/Pages/WhatareHumanRights.
aspx, last visited May 14, 2010.
United Nations Treaty Collection Database. Available at
http://treaties.un.org, last visited Sept. 4, 2013.
UVIN, Peter. Human Rights and Development. Bloomfield:
Kumarian Press, Inc., 2004.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5102/rdi.v10i2.2598
ISSN 2236-997X (impresso) - ISSN 2237-1036 (on-line)
Desenvolvido por:
